Magikarp CGC 9.5
CGC 9.5 price history
A CGC 9.5 English Magikarp (XY Black Star Promos XY143/211) is worth about €320 (≈ $356), based on 4 sales in the last 12 months, blended with an estimate from CGC 10 (15 CGC 10 sales). Fair value updated Oct 28, 2026. About 6 in 10 sales land between €161 and €391. A CGC 10 is about €657 and a PSA 10 about €3,115.
Terms used:Fair value Sales 12m Range Grade CGC
Completed sales from eBay, Fanatics Collect and Goldin · live asks from Cardmarket · How fair value works · USD at the ECB rate of Oct 27, 2026
Live CGC 9.5 asks
Cardmarket offers in EUR, cheapest first
No live Cardmarket asks for this grade right now.
Recent CGC 9.5 sales
The last completed sales in every language, in EUR
| Date | Language | Marketplace | Title | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oct 19, 2026 | en | ebay | 2016 POKEMON XY BLACK STAR PROMO SHINY MEGA GYARADOS MAGIKARP-HOLO CGC 9.5 #XY143 [eBay] | €191.54 |
| Oct 6, 2026 | en | ebay | 2016 POKEMON BLACK STAR PROMOS #XY143 MAGIKARP CGC 9.5 [eBay] | €271.76 |
| Mar 29, 2026 | en | ebay | Pokemon Magikarp Shiny Mega Gyarados Bx. Holo Promo XY143 CGC 9.5 [eBay] | €427.10 |
| Jan 6, 2026 | en | ebay | 2016 Pokémon XY Black Star Promo Magikarp-Holo #XY143 CGC 9.5 MINT+ [eBay] | €102.50 |
| Aug 22, 2025 | en | ebay | CGC 9.5 Blue Label Magikarp XY143 Black Star Promo Shiny M Gyarados Box Pokemon #XY143 [eBay] | €258.44 |
Card details
- Set
- XY Black Star Promos
- Number
- XY143/211
- Rarity
- Promo
- Illustrator
- Saya Tsuruta
By language
CGC 9.5 fair values, sales and live asks for every printing language
| Language | Fair value | Confidence | Sales 12m | Last sale | Population | Offers | Lowest ask |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| en | €3204 sales + estimate from CGC 10 (15 CGC 10 sales) | Medium | 4 | Oct 19, 2026 · €191.54 | – | – | – |
Frequently asked questions
How much is a CGC 9.5 Magikarp worth?
A CGC 9.5 English Magikarp (XY Black Star Promos XY143/211) is worth about €320 (≈ $356), based on 4 sales in the last 12 months, blended with an estimate from CGC 10 (15 CGC 10 sales). Fair value updated Oct 28, 2026. About 6 in 10 sales land between €161 and €391. A CGC 10 is about €657 and a PSA 10 about €3,115.
Is a CGC 9.5 Magikarp worth more than a CGC 10?
No. A CGC 10 is about €657, 2.1× a CGC 9.5 at about €320.
How fast does a CGC 9.5 Magikarp sell?
None sold on EU venues in the last 90 days (2 copies on all venues), so there is no EU pace to time a sale from. Listed at €320, one copy nets about €289 on Cardmarket after fees.
Other grades
Magikarp grades with at least three sales in the last 12 months